|
|
 |
Proactive Patient
Medical mistakes, though uncommon, could be deadly. Learn how to protect yourself in five possible situations.
By Yasmine IqbalIn a perfect world, nobody would ever get
sick or injured or need medical care. In a near-perfect world,
health care systems would always provide high-quality care and
medical professionals would make unerring diagnoses and prescribe or
perform exactly the right treatments.
But in our imperfect world, hospitals, doctors, and other health
care professionals can and do make mistakes. A much-publicized 1999
study by the Institute of Medicine estimated that medical mistakes
could kill as many as 98,000 people in U.S. hospitals every year. A
more recent study by the health care ratings company HealthGrades
estimated that the number of “patient safety incidents” in hospitals
rose to 1.24 million between 2002 and 2004, up from 1.14 million
over the previous three years.
But there is good news. “The media tends to focus on the
sensationalistic stories, but there’s a lot of good that’s being
done as well,” says Diane Pinakiewicz, president of the National
Patient Safety Foundation, a nonprofit organization dedicated to
reducing health care errors. “The health care industry is
recognizing that errors do happen and finding proactive ways to
correct the processes that lead to those mistakes. They’re also
encouraging patients and their family members to take a proactive
role in detecting and preventing errors.”
Following are five kinds of medical mistakes and problems that can
lead to mistakes, what the health care industry is doing to prevent
them, and what you can do to ensure that they don’t happen to you or
a loved one.
1. Confusing medical directions or advice
Too often, patients leave the doctor’s office or hospital without
a clear understanding of how they’re supposed to care for
themselves. Consider asthma, a condition that affects thousands and
needs daily management. A 2005 Global Asthma Physician and Patient
survey of 6,000 doctors showed that 85 percent devote less than half
of their time to communicating key facts about asthma management.
“People are often too afraid or intimidated to ask questions about
their health care — if they don’t understand something, they just
smile and nod,” says Dr. James Battles, a senior service fellow for
patient safety at the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and
Quality (AHRQ).
What’s being done: Doctors are recognizing the need to
communicate more thoroughly and effectively, even if they’re limited
in the time that they can spend with patients. National physician
organizations like the American Academy of Family Physicians and the
American College of Physicians have issued guidelines and created
teaching modules to help physicians improve their communication
skills, and most doctors have brochures and instruction sheets that
explain conditions and treatments in detail.
What you can do: “If you don’t understand something, or if
you need more information, you need to speak up and demand clear
answers — that’s what you’re paying your doctors for,” says Battles.
Experts recommend taking a list of questions to every doctor’s visit
and writing down or tape recording the answers so you can review
them later. Also, consider asking a family member or friend to come
with you to serve as another pair of ears and ask questions that
might not occur to you.
2. Missed diagnoses
Doctors have an array of diagnostic tools and tests to get to the
root of medical problems, but they don’t always follow up on test
results. A 2005 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine
examined the medical records of more than 2,500 patients at
Boston-area hospitals and found their doctors didn’t always know
about test results that signaled a serious problem; in some cases,
they didn’t even know that certain tests had been ordered.
What’s being done: Some hospitals are setting up computer
systems that electronically alert doctors when a suspicious test
result comes in. At the VA Ann Arbor (Mich.) Healthcare System, for
example, radiologists code each medical image; a “Code 8” tag, for
example, indicates an unexpected sign of cancer that requires
immediate follow-up. Doctors are alerted to the Code 8 scans by a
written report and a phone call, which prevents patients who could
have cancer from falling through the cracks.
It’s also becoming easier to transmit images from X-ray, MRI, CT,
and PET scans over the Internet, so doctors can access them right
after a test is complete. This reduces chances that the results will
be lost and helps ensure more immediate treatment.
What you can do: Never assume that no news is good news. Call
the doctor or hospital and ask about test results. Also, if all the
tests turn out negative but you still think something is wrong,
don’t hesitate to pursue the problem by getting a second (or even
third or fourth) opinion.
3. Wrong-site surgery
This is perhaps the most horrifying and dramatic kind of medical
mistake: A patient wakes up after surgery to find that the wrong
limb has been operated on or the wrong procedure has been performed.
Wrong-site surgery encompasses all surgical procedures performed on
the wrong patient, wrong body part, wrong side of the body, or at
the wrong level of the correctly identified anatomic site. As of
December 2005, 455 wrong-site surgeries had been reported to the
Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations, a
nonprofit agency that evaluates and accredits health care
facilities.
What’s being done: Studies show that most wrong-site
surgeries occur in orthopedic cases, and orthopedic surgeons were
the first group to formally tackle this issue. In 1998 the American
Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons created the “Sign Your Site”
campaign, reminding surgeons to mark the surgical site with their
initials before making the first incision. In 2004, the Joint
Commission made surgical site marking mandatory for all accredited
hospitals and surgery centers.
What you can do: Ask your surgeon to mark the surgical site
before you are sedated or anesthetized so you can ensure it’s in the
correct place. Also, ask if the surgical team routinely takes a
“time out” just before the surgery begins. During a time out, the
team takes a few critical moments to assure themselves that they are
performing the correct procedure at the correct site on the correct
person.
4. Health care-associated infections
You might correlate the antiseptic smell of doctors’ offices or
hospitals with cleanliness, but the truth is, health care facilities
are breeding grounds for infectious diseases such as pneumonia,
hepatitis, and tuberculosis, which can be passed between health care
workers and patients. These infections, which are called health
care-associated infections, affect approximately 2 million people
and cause 90,000 deaths annually, according to the Centers for
Disease Control (CDC).
What’s being done: The CDC has numerous guidelines for
protecting patients from health care-associated infections,
including specific instructions for managing surgical incisions,
ventilators, catheters, and other procedures and devices that make
patients vulnerable to infection.
What you can do: Many health care-associated infections are
transmitted from patient to patient through a seemingly innocuous
source: the hands of health care workers. Make sure that every
medical professional who touches you cleans his or her hands first
by washing them or using a hand-sanitizer gel.
5. Medication errors
According to the AHRQ, 7,000 people die each year from taking the
wrong kind or dosage of medication or taking it in the wrong way.
Adverse medication reactions are responsible for more than 4 million
doctor visits every year, according to a 2005 AHRQ study. Many of
these incidents could be prevented if patients knew more about the
medicines they take and how and when to take them.
What’s being done: Many hospitals, doctors’ offices, and
pharmacies now have computer systems in place that can detect and
flag possible drug interactions. Pharmacists, who are experts in
medications and medication management, also are providing more
one-on-one consultations with patients to answer their medication
questions.
What you can do: Experts recommend the following:
■ Tell your doctor about all the medications you’re taking,
including prescription and over-the-counter medicines and dietary
supplements such as vitamins and herbs.
■ Make sure your doctor knows about any medications you’re
allergic to and any adverse reactions you’ve had.
■ If your doctor handwrites your prescription, make sure you can
read it, and when you pick up the medicine from the pharmacy, make
sure the type and dosage are correct.
■ Make sure you understand everything about what the medicine is
for, how to take it and for how long, and possible side effects —
and what to do about them.
What’s the take-home message? Find medical professionals you trust,
but trust your own judgment and instincts as well, and speak up if
something doesn’t seem right. “By being vigilant, engaged, and
informed, patients can work with health care providers to prevent
mistakes from happening,” says Pinakiewicz. “They can and should
become partners in their own health care.”
On the Web
|